👉 Obviously, the white ones… right? 😏
❌ Harmful chemicals (like SLS, Fluoride overload, Triclosan)
❌ Visiting the dentist
❌ Spending shit loads of money
Slay your smile with Perfora 🪥
Trusted by 10 lakh+ users, Perfora makes oral care simple, effective, and honest — so you can smile confidently, every day. 💙🪥
🚨 Problem Statement (With Specific Audience)
💬 “My teeth never feel fully clean — even after brushing twice.”
💬 “I want whitening but don’t trust harsh chemicals or dentist visits.”
India’s oral care market is dominated by legacy brands that rely on abrasive ingredients and lack innovation.
📊 According to a Kantar survey (2023), 68% of urban millennials are dissatisfied with their current oral care routine.
This issue is most common among Gen Z and working professionals aged 25–35, who seek safer, more effective solutions that match their lifestyle.
Feature | Pain Point Solved |
---|---|
⚡ Electric Toothbrush with 4 Modes | Lack of deep cleaning, brushing inconsistency |
🧴 Clean, chemical-free toothpaste | Sensitivity from SLS and other harsh ingredients |
✨ Whitening Serum (PAP-based) | Harsh whitening methods, expensive dentist treatments |
💨 Spray Mouthwash | Convenience, no messy rinsing — ideal for travel and daily routines |
🧪 Dentist-backed R&D | Builds trust for skeptical buyers |
Parameter | Aditya Kandukuri | Ananya Rathi | Rohan Mehta | Shruti Patel | Karan Sethi |
Age | 30 | 26 | 32 | 28 | 23 |
Gender | Male | Female | Male | Female | Male |
Location | Gurgaon | New Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore | Pune |
Occupation | Tech Professional | Consultant | Sales Manager | Designer | MBA Student |
Income | ₹80K/month | ₹60K/month | ₹70K/month | ₹55K/month | ₹25K/month |
Products Used | Electric Toothbrush | Full Oral Set | Mouth Spray, Whitening Kit | Whitening Serum, Brush | Toothbrush, Cleaner |
Usage Frequency | Daily | Twice Daily | Weekly | Daily | Daily |
Pain Point Solved | Tech brushing | Complete care | Fresh breath on-the-go | Home whitening | Affordable care |
Experience (1–5) | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 |
Shopping Channel | Swiggy/Blinkit | D2C Website | Blinkit, Amazon | Instagram Ad | Blinkit |
Discovery Source | Swiggy Instamart | Shark Tank | Blinkit | Referral | |
Trigger for First Purchase | Tech features | Trust in Shark Tank | Impulse buy | Whitening need | Recommendation |
Repeat Purchase Behavior | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Barrier to Upgrade | None | Price for full kit | None | Want more whitening speed | Limited budget |
Preferred Routine | Electric brushing | Full care (whiten+brush) | Quick freshen-up | Whitening-focused | Basic brush & clean |
Likelihood to Recommend (1–10) | 9 | 8 | 9 | 8 | 7 |
If Perfora stopped selling... | Very disappointed | Disappointed | Very disappointed | Very disappointed | Somewhat disappointed |
What you LOVE about them? | Tech features, design | Complete kit, results | Instant freshness, value | Visible whitening | Affordable, simple to use |
What needs work / dislike? | Battery life | Price for bundle | Availability | Whitening speed | Brush durability |
Parameter | Meenal (Churned) | Rishi (Churned) |
---|---|---|
Age | 29 | 30 |
Gender | Female | Male |
Location | Pune | Delhi |
Occupation | Sales Executive | IT Consultant |
Income | ₹35K/month | ₹50K/month |
Products Tried | Toothpaste, Mouthwash | Electric Toothbrush |
Usage Frequency | Occasionally | Weekly |
Pain Point Solved | No visible change | Expensive, Battery |
Experience (1–5) | 3 | 2 |
Shopping Channel | Blinkit, Nykaa | Flipkart, Amazon |
Discovery Source | ||
Trigger for First Purchase | Discount | Friend referral |
Repeat Purchase Behavior | No | No |
Barrier to Upgrade | Price | Battery reliability |
Preferred Routine | Basic brushing | Manual brushing |
Likelihood to Recommend | 4 | 3 |
Reason for Churn | No value for money | Switched to Sensodyne |
Current Brand Used | Colgate | Sensodyne |
Parameter | Saumya (Universal) | Rohit (Universal) |
---|---|---|
Age | 27 | 25 |
Gender | Female | Male |
Location | Gurgaon | Bangalore |
Occupation | Marketing Executive | Student |
Income | ₹45K/month | ₹20K/month |
Products Used | None | None |
Usage Frequency | N/A | N/A |
Pain Point | Trust, Availability | Price, Satisfied already |
Experience (1–5) | — | — |
Shopping Channel | Not tried | Not tried |
Discovery Source | Instagram Ads | Blinkit |
Trigger for First Purchase | Not yet | Not yet |
Repeat Purchase Behavior | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Barrier to Upgrade | Trust, Access | Price barrier |
Preferred Routine | Basic brushing | Basic brushing |
Likelihood to Recommend | — | — |
Current Brand Used | Colgate | Pepsodent |
Interest Level | Medium | Low |
Based on adoption curve, appetite to pay, and distribution potential, the top 3 ICPs that should be prioritized are
Parameter | ICP 1: Electric Toothbrush – Techie Aditya | ICP 2: Full Oral Kit – Consultant Ananya | ICP 3: Whitening Serum – Designer Shruti |
---|---|---|---|
Age | 30 | 26 | 28 |
Gender | Male | Female | Female |
Location | Gurgaon | New Delhi | Bangalore |
Occupation | Tech Professional | Consultant | Designer |
Income | ₹80K/month | ₹60K/month | ₹55K/month |
Product Focus | Electric Toothbrush | Full Oral Kit (Toothpaste, Mouthwash, Cleaner) | Whitening Serum + Brush |
Usage Frequency | Daily | Twice Daily | Daily |
Pain Point Solved | Brushing tech, deep clean, time-efficient | Complete care routine, all-in-one solution | Whitening at home without dentist visits |
Shopping Channel | Swiggy Instamart, Blinkit | D2C Website | Instagram Ad |
Discovery Source | Swiggy Ads | Shark Tank | |
Trigger for First Purchase | Tech Features | Shark Tank Trust | Need for Whitening |
Repeat Purchase Behavior | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Barrier to Upgrade | None | High price for full kit | Wants faster whitening results |
Preferred Routine | Daily Tech Brushing | Whiten + Brush Combo | Whitening Focused |
Likelihood to Recommend (1-10) | 9 | 8 | 8 |
NPS Category | Promoter | Promoter | Promoter |
Perfora Discontinued? | Very Disappointed | Disappointed | Very Disappointed |
What They Love | Tech brush, clean feel, easy brushing | Full kit ease, complete oral care | Whitening works, design of product |
What Needs Work | Battery life could improve | Pricey | Whitening speed, more visible results |
(Before you begin, you need to know what your product is, what are its features, what is the problem being solved by your product?)
(Build your core value proposition by exact what your product does and what problem are you solving)
Perfora is a modern oral care brand from India, focused on delivering safe, clean, and effective products for better daily dental health. Unlike traditional brands which are loaded with harsh chemicals and fake claims, Perfora offers transparent, toxin-free solutions that elevate your oral care routine. With a focus on real results, aesthetics, and ease of use, Perfora helps you achieve whiter, healthier teeth — at home, without visiting the dentist.
💡To revolutionize daily oral care by offering clean, personalized, and effective solutions that help Gen Z and millennials slay their smile game and achieve their oral hygiene #goals—confidently, safely, and in style
Perfora is redefining oral care for the modern Indian consumer — focusing on teeth whitening, personalization, and next-level oral hygiene. With clean ingredients, bold designs, and cutting-edge tools, Perfora helps users upgrade from boring brushing to a cool, modern, and effective oral care experience.
Perfora solves the yellow teeth problem with a range of safe, at-home whitening products — no dentist visits, no harmful chemicals, just visible results. 🦷✨
From electric toothbrushes to power flossers, Perfora offers tech-enabled oral care. Plus, subscription refills and tailored routines make it personal and hassle-free. 🪥🔌
Forget boring oral care. Perfora’s colorful, minimalist packaging and Instagram-friendly aesthetic make it fun, fresh, and something users love to show off. 🤳🏻
No SLS, Triclosan, or fake claims. Perfora is 100% honest — every ingredient is listed, every promise is real, and users trust what they use.✅
Perfora is more than a product — it’s a lifestyle upgrade. With 10L+ happy users, it helps people smile confidently every single day — at home, on their terms.
Parameter | Perfora | Colgate/Pepsodent | Oral-B | SALT | Philips/Xiaomi |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Core Problem Solved | Yellow teeth, chemical-free care, tech-driven brushing, teeth whitening at home | Basic hygiene, affordable oral care | Effective plaque removal via tech | Natural, sustainable oral hygiene | Easy and affordable tech brushing |
Products/Features | Electric brush, floss, whitening kits, mouth spray | Toothpaste, manual brush, mouthwash | Electric brush, manual brush | Natural toothpaste, manual brush | Electric toothbrushes only |
Target Audience | Health-conscious Gen Z/Millennials, urban buyers | Mass market, all demographics | Urban, tech-aware professionals | Premium, eco-conscious segment | Budget-conscious tech buyers |
Key USP | Teeth whitening at home, personalisation, clean ingredients | Trusted legacy, affordability | Tech innovation in brushing | Natural ingredients, Ayurveda-inspired | Value for money, tech features |
Distribution | D2C, Blinkit, Amazon, Nykaa | Kirana stores, supermarkets, online | Offline + Online | Online + Select offline | Amazon, Flipkart, Mi/Philips stores |
Price Range | ₹300–₹3,000 | ₹50–₹200 | ₹100–₹5,000 | ₹80–₹500 | ₹1,000–₹3,500 |
Ingredient Transparency | Very High (No SLS, Fluoride overload, Triclosan) | Low/Moderate | Moderate | Very High | Not applicable (hardware only) |
Packaging | Colorful, modern, minimalistic | Standard mass-market | Functional, tech-focused | Eco-friendly, earthy tones | Sleek, tech-centric |
Market Positioning | Premium tech-enabled oral care, D2C | Affordable everyday oral care | Trusted tech oral care | Sustainable wellness | Affordable electric hygiene |
Social Media Presence | High (Instagram, Shark Tank recall, influencers) | Moderate (mass campaigns) | Moderate | Moderate | Low |
Strengths | Whitening + tech + clean, strong brand recall | Distribution, pricing, trust | Tech expertise, brand trust | Natural positioning, loyal niche | Budget-friendly, large distribution |
Weaknesses | Limited reach, higher price, niche segment | Chemical-loaded, low innovation | Expensive for mass users | Niche appeal, limited range | No oral care brand connect, low support |
Criteria | Share | Count | Reasoning | Source |
---|---|---|---|---|
Total Population | 100% | ~1,440,000,000 | Total population of India (2024 est.) used for market sizing | https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/india-population/ |
Access to Modern Oral Care | 20% | ~280,000,000 | Urban & semi-urban population with access to modern oral care products | https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS?locations=IN |
Target Segment (Health Conscious) | 10% | ~28,000,000 | Health-conscious, educated, tech-savvy buyers | https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109017/india-public-awareness-of-healthy-lifestyle-measures/ |
Market Penetration (SOM) | 10% | ~2,800,000 | Realistic share based on D2C awareness, pricing, competition | Industry Assumption (D2C oral care penetration levels) |
ARPU | ₹2,000/user | ₹2,000 annually | Avg. yearly spend/user (toothbrush, flossers, whitening, mouthwash) | Based on Perfora pricing and D2C oral care trends |
Perfora is in the early scaling phase, having achieved strong Product-Market Fit (PMF) with a growing base of loyal users. Their focus is now on scaling efficiently by targeting urban, health-conscious individuals through tech-driven oral care solutions like electric toothbrushes, whitening kits, and flossers. The brand aims to expand awareness, increase repeat purchases, and introduce more users to premium oral care.
Channel Name | Cost | Flexibility | Effort | Scale |
---|---|---|---|---|
Organic | Low | High | Medium | Medium |
Paid Ads | High | High | High | High |
Referral Program | Medium | Medium | Low | Medium |
Product Integration | Medium | Low | High | Medium–High |
Content Loops | Low | High | High | Medium |
We will be focusing on 3 key acquisition channels: Paid Ads, Referral Program and Product Integration for enhancing the user base of Perfora.
Given that the product is in the early scaling stage, it is important to prioritize acquisition channels that can provide a significant impact on growth while being cost-effective and flexible. Here are the top three channels we should focus on, along with a brief setup and experimental ideas:
Why Prioritize? Organic search is a powerful channel for long-term growth. It is cost-effective and can scale as your content gains traction. In the early scaling stage, establishing a strong presence in search engines helps drive consistent and high-quality traffic.
Experiment: Identify a niche keyword or topic cluster that your competitors are not heavily targeting but aligns with your product's strengths. Create a series of blog posts, guides, or videos around this topic and optimize them for SEO. Measure the impact on traffic and conversions over time.
Channel Name | Cost | Flexibility | Effort | Speed | Scale | Budget |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Google Search | Medium | High | Medium | High | High | Medium |
Google YouTube | Low | High | High | Medium | High | Low |
Low | High | Medium | Medium | Medium | Low | |
Low | Medium | High | Medium | Medium | Medium | |
Programmatic | High | Medium | High | High | High | High |
Amazon Ads | Medium | Medium | High | High | High | High |
The queries will be divided into four categories:
Here’s a list of sample queries, categorized and evaluated:
Query | Category | Effort | Time to Validate | Scale (Volume) |
---|---|---|---|---|
What are the best electric toothbrushes? | Use-case/Problem | Medium | Short | High |
Perfora electric toothbrush reviews | Brand Name | Low | Short | Medium |
OralB vs Perfora comparison | Competitor Name | Medium | Medium | High |
How to brush teeth effectively? | Use-case Topic | Medium | Medium | High |
Perfora customer testimonials | Brand Name | Low | Short | Medium |
Best electric toothbrush for sensitive teeth | Use-case/Problem | Medium | Medium | High |
OralB customer reviews | Competitor Name | Medium | Medium | High |
Perfora electric toothbrush warranty | Brand Name | Low | Short | Medium |
How to choose the right toothbrush? | Use-case Topic | Medium | Medium | High |
OralB electric toothbrush alternatives | Competitor Name | Medium | Medium | High |
Keywords to be Optimized:
For each selected keyword, create content in the form of:
Monitoring & Measuring Impact:
To determine the best channel for SEO, let's evaluate options like Google Search, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, etc., based on the criteria: cost, flexibility, effort, speed, scale, and budget. Here's a comparison table:
Channel | Cost | Flexibility | Effort | Speed (Results) | Scale (Reach) | Budget Need |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Google Search | Medium | High | Medium | High | High | Medium |
YouTube (Google) | Low | High | High | Medium | High | Low |
Facebook Search | Low | High | Medium | Medium | Medium | Low |
Instagram Search | Low | Medium | High | Medium | Medium | Medium |
Programmatic Ads | High | Medium | High | High | High | High |
Amazon Ads | Medium | Medium | High | High | High | High |
The queries will be divided into four categories:
Here’s a list of sample queries, categorized and evaluated:
Query | Category | Effort to Rank | Validation Time | Search Volume |
---|---|---|---|---|
What are the best electric toothbrushes? | Use-case / Problem | Medium | Short | High |
Perfora electric toothbrush reviews | Brand Name | Low | Short | Medium |
OralB vs Perfora comparison | Competitor Name | Medium | Medium | High |
How to brush teeth effectively? | Use-case Topic | Medium | Medium | High |
Perfora customer testimonials | Brand Name | Low | Short | Medium |
Best toothbrush for sensitive teeth | Use-case / Problem | Medium | Medium | High |
OralB customer reviews | Competitor Name | Medium | Medium | High |
Perfora electric toothbrush warranty | Brand Name | Low | Short | Medium |
How to choose the right toothbrush? | Use-case Topic | Medium | Medium | High |
OralB electric toothbrush alternatives | Competitor Name | Medium | Medium | High |
For each selected keyword, create content in the form of:
Use tools like Google Analytics, Ahrefs, or SEMrush to measure:
💡 Idea | 🎯 Hook (What grabs attention?) | ✍️ Generator (Who creates it?) | 📲 Distribution (How it spreads?) |
Myth-Busting Oral Care Hacks | Brushing harder doesn’t mean cleaner teeth! (Busting common myths) | Perfora Team, Dentists, Influencers | Instagram Reels, YouTube Shorts, Twitter Threads |
Unbox My Oral Care Routine | Here’s what I use to keep my teeth white! (Relatable + aspirational) | Influencers, Power Users, Perfora Team | Instagram, YouTube, Blogs, LinkedIn |
Perfora Labs (Educational Series) | Here’s what’s really inside your toothpaste (Ingredient-focused, value-based) | Perfora Team, Dentists, Experts | YouTube, Instagram Carousels, SEO Blog, LinkedIn |
✨ White Smile Challenge | Can you get visibly whiter teeth in 7 days? (Challenge format, UGC-friendly) | Users, Influencers, Perfora Team | Instagram Stories, Reels, Community Shares |
😱 Oral Care Red Flags | Stop doing this one thing – it’s damaging your teeth! (Quick-fix appeal) | Perfora Team, Influencers | Instagram Reels, YouTube Shorts, Twitter Threads |
🧳 What’s In My Travel Kit? | I never travel without these 3 oral care essentials (Relatable, lifestyle vibe) | Travel Influencers, Real Users, Perfora Team | Travel Vlogs, Instagram Reels, Newsletters |
🪞 Glow-Up Routine: Teeth Edition | I levelled up my smile game – skincare glow-up wasn’t enough (Lifestyle upgrade) | Beauty/Lifestyle Influencers, Perfora Ambassadors | Instagram, YouTube, Blogs |
🎙️ Dentist Diaries Podcast Series | Founder & Dentist decode oral care myths & tips (Expert-backed, trust-builder) | Perfora Founder, Dentists | YouTube Long Form, Shorts, Instagram Reels, LinkedIn Clips |
(Understand what is already being done, what is working out well and what needs to be stopped)
Step 1 → Define the CAC: LTV ratio. If your product has a healthy CAC:LTV ratio, proceed with paid ads.
Step 2 → Choose an ICP
Step 3 → Select advertising channels
Step 4 → Write a Marketing Pitch
Step 5 → Customize your message for different customer segments to ensure relevance
Step 6 → Design at least two ad creatives (e.g., images, sketches, videos, text ads) that reflect your marketing pitch.
Note : Since CAC:LTV = 1:3.75, Perfora has a healthy ratio > 3, making paid acquisition viable and scalable.
Metric | Description | Perfora (Estimated) |
---|---|---|
CAC | Customer Acquisition Cost | ₹400 |
ARPU | Average Revenue Per User / Month | ₹250 |
Margin | Gross Margin | 50% |
Retention | Customer Lifetime (Months) | 12 |
LTV | ARPU × Margin × Retention | ₹250 × 0.5 × 12 = ₹1,500 |
CAC:LTV | Ratio of CAC to LTV | 1:3.75 |
Note : Since CAC:LTV = 1:3.75, Perfora has a healthy ratio > 3, making paid acquisition viable and scalable. |
Paid Advertising Channel | Effort | Cost | Flexibility | Lead Time (Speed) | Scale |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Google Search Ads | Medium | High | High | Low | High |
YouTube Ads | High | Medium | High | Medium | High |
Meta (Facebook) | Medium | Medium | High | Low | High |
Meta (Instagram) | Medium | Low | High | Low | High |
Amazon Ads | High | High | Medium | Medium | Medium |
Image/Video 1
Image/Video 2
Image/Video 3
Image/Video 4
Targeting (IG Audience)
ICP | Persona Snapshot |
---|---|
Techie Aditya | 30, Gurgaon, ₹80K/month, uses electric toothbrush daily for tech + time reasons |
Consultant Ananya | 26, New Delhi, ₹60K/month, prefers complete oral care kit with premium quality |
Designer Shruti | 28, Bangalore, ₹55K/month, seeks fast teeth whitening at home |
All 3 have strong repeat behavior and are current Perfora users who prefer fast delivery and discovery via Blinkit/Swiggy Instamart/Instagram Ads — aligning perfectly with Blinkit's hyperlocal commerce model.
🌟 Product Integration Framework (Perfora)
Product your ICP most interacts with | Frequency of these interactions | Importance of these interactions | Can Perfora add value to these interactions? | Potential to get customers new use cases |
---|---|---|---|---|
Swiggy Instamart / Blinkit | High | Very | Yes – seamless delivery for oral care needs | High |
Practo (Dental Appointments) | Medium | Very | Yes – dentist-backed product recommendations | High |
Urban Company (Salon/Dental Care) | Medium | Very | Yes – oral care package upsell | Medium |
PharmEasy / 1mg | High | Very | Yes – dental health bundle | High |
Nykaa | Medium | Somewhat | Yes – beauty + oral care bundle | Medium |
Why Instamart/ Blinkit is the Right Partner
Reason | Justification |
---|---|
High Purchase Frequency | Oral care is a high-frequency repeat category (daily use) |
Fast Delivery Infrastructure | Blinkit enables <10 min access for urgent needs like travel kits or replacements |
Discovery-Driven Users | ICPs are already discovering products via Blinkit ads & app sections |
Impulse-Friendly Format | Blinkit's homepage & category banners encourage quick trials |
Urban Tech-Savvy Users | Blinkit users = same Tier-1 metro demographic Perfora targets |
In-App Integration
1.
2. Slider Banner in Oral Care Section
Validate what works before full-scale integration
Before full fledged Run Pilot Can be Run for Short Duration in top cities where Perfora has traction already
Example:
Track KPIs to prove success and scale smartly
📊 Key Metrics to Measure:
User opens the Blinkit app
⬇
Sees top banner: “✨ Smile Brighter in 7 Days with Perfora”
⬇
Clicks on it → Lands on collection page with bundles, trial packs
⬇
Sees price (₹99 trial), clean ingredients, fast delivery
⬇
Adds to cart → Impulse trial purchase
User casually browsing the app
⬇
Scrolls through trending section → Sees “🪥 Perfora: Gen Z’s Pick for Oral Care”
⬇
Clicks → Opens dedicated collection (Starter Pack, Whitening Kit, etc.)
⬇
Reads “Why Try This?” – benefits, ingredients, reviews
⬇
Chooses combo/trial → Converts
User browsing: Bath & Body → Oral Care
⬇
Sees banner: “🦷 Chemical-Free Whitening in 7 Days – Perfora”
⬇
Clicks → Lands on curated kit options: Electric Brush + Spray, Whitening + Floss, etc.
⬇
Filters price, delivery time → Adds tech brush or starter kit
⬇
Switches from traditional brand → Converts
User types: “whitening toothpaste” / “sensitive toothbrush”
⬇
Search results show Colgate, Sensodyne, AND Perfora
⬇
Perfora highlighted with tag: “Try Whitening Kit @ ₹99”
⬇
Clicks on product page → Reads comparison vs Closeup/Sensodyne
⬇
Sees natural ingredients, dentist-recommended, positive reviews
⬇
Adds to cart → Replaces traditional product
User checking “⚡ Lowest Prices Ever” section
⬇
Finds: “Perfora Electric Brush – Now ₹999 (was ₹1399)”
⬇
Checks reviews & value → Sees bundle option: “Add spray for ₹149 more”
⬇
Chooses combo → Adds to cart → Buys
User scrolls through “🔥 Trending Near You” shelf
⬇
Spots: “Perfora Spray + Floss Kit – Trending in your area”
⬇
Clicks → Sees “Delivered in 10 minutes”, minimalist design, top reviews
⬇
Feels safe trying what’s trending + low-risk due to speed
⬇
🛒 Adds to cart → Completes order
Brand focused courses
Great brands aren't built on clicks. They're built on trust. Craft narratives that resonate, campaigns that stand out, and brands that last.
All courses
Master every lever of growth — from acquisition to retention, data to events. Pick a course, go deep, and apply it to your business right away.
Explore foundations by GrowthX
Built by Leaders From Amazon, CRED, Zepto, Hindustan Unilever, Flipkart, paytm & more
Crack a new job or a promotion with the Career Centre
Designed for mid-senior & leadership roles across growth, product, marketing, strategy & business
Learning Resources
Browse 500+ case studies, articles & resources the learning resources that you won't find on the internet.
Patience—you’re about to be impressed.